Broken S8 for Project or spares

Audi A8 D2's for sale. Facelift and Pre-facelift.
Post Reply
markiii
Posts: 8
Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2026 1:41 pm

Broken S8 for Project or spares

Post by markiii »

Some of you will have seen my original advert for my S8 some time ago.

It still the same basic car as below however it has a minor wrinkle. The gearbox has shit the bed.

Having done a fluid change the problem has not improved.

It will move under its own power in reverse, it will move forward with no throttle, but as soon as throttle is used the box goes clunk and the PRNDS lights up.
So, it’s going to need gearbox work. 2 specialists have quoted me £5k to do this and honestly if I was going to keep it I’d do it or DIY.

Alas I’ve been running it’s replacement for some time and wouldn’t be keeping it. DIY is out as my garage is not long enough to shut the doors with an S8 in let alone take one to bits.
Since I’m trying to move house at the moment, I also don’t have the time.

Short version its not getting fixed in my ownership.

So I have 3 choices

• Scrap it. I’d really rather not as it’s a good car. And had a lot of work done by Millo in the past. Its also worth sod all that way and I suspect won’t be doing anything to keep other cars alive/
• Break it for parts possible, though my time is limited
• Sell it as is as a Project to someone with the will/time/skill to get it back up and running

So if anyone is interested as a project or in parts, please let me know!

Original advert details below (the Stereo System has now been removed)

https://forum.a8parts.co.uk/showthread.php?t=17383
User avatar
HPsauce
Posts: 186
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2025 4:24 pm
Location: South Bucks UK

Re: Broken S8 for Project or spares

Post by HPsauce »

I won't be the first to ask; what a VCDS scan shows? Without that no-one has a clue how bad the gearbox problem is.
Also, will it actually drive in limp mode (PRNDS lit) as that usually means its locked in 3rd (4th?) gear but still drives.
MikkiJayne
Posts: 248
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2023 6:26 pm

Re: Broken S8 for Project or spares

Post by MikkiJayne »

Sorry to hear this :cry:

Based on the symptoms:

"It will move under its own power in reverse, it will move forward with no throttle, but as soon as throttle is used the box goes clunk and the PRNDS lights up."

VCDS will show "gear ratio incorrect". This is almost certainly the A-drum disintegrated, or at best the thrust bearing holding it together is now in the sump. It definitely mechanical, not electrical.

They are usually about £1K on the open market with a broken gearbox. Not sure if Prestige are still buying them, but it wouldn't be for much since they have transport to pay for as well.
markiii
Posts: 8
Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2026 1:41 pm

Re: Broken S8 for Project or spares

Post by markiii »

good shout MJ

VCDS Says

1 Fault Found:

17114 - Gear Ratio Monitoring
P0730 - 35-00 - Incorrect Gear Ratio

it will roll forward fine without throttle but won't go up through the gears at the speed it can get to on my drive, and I'm not taking it off the drive for fear it won't make it back up the hill
markiii
Posts: 8
Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2026 1:41 pm

Re: Broken S8 for Project or spares

Post by markiii »

In the mean time should anyone wish to part ex things like Final Edition wheels or the Canadian spec all red tail lights against your stock stuff please shout
User avatar
HPsauce
Posts: 186
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2025 4:24 pm
Location: South Bucks UK

Re: Broken S8 for Project or spares

Post by HPsauce »

Stevenage isn't too far for me, what's the condition/type/quantity of the FE wheels, e.g. still diamond cut or repainted, genuine 8.5" or later (D3) 9", welds/repairs, tyres etc. and what do you want to swap them for?
Your original ad mentions PS4S tyres, what's the date code and wear level?
Fredde9912
Posts: 32
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 5:30 pm

Re: Broken S8 for Project or spares

Post by Fredde9912 »

markiii wrote: Fri Sep 25, 2026 10:50 am In the mean time should anyone wish to part ex things like Final Edition wheels or the Canadian spec all red tail lights against your stock stuff please shout
What are those Canadian lights? Never heard of them are they different from US spec?
Post Reply